Alien vs Aliens

Which is better: Alien or Aliens? Jaws in space or Rambo in space? Two movies enter; one movie leaves. There can be only one Alien movie. 

Brad's Golden Idols

1. Best Location: ALIEN Derelict aircraft with Space Jockey

2. Best Character: TIE Ripley

3. Best Screen Duo: ALIENS Ripley & Hicks

4. Best Villain/Antagonist: ALIENS Carter Burke

5. Best Hero/Protagonist: ALIENS Ripley

6. Best Kill: ALIEN Chestburster

7. WTF: ALIEN Behind The Scenes Alien was going to bite off Ripley's head

8. Best Score or Soundtrack: ALIEN

9. Best Quote: ALIENS 'Get away from her, you bitch!'

10. Best Screenplay: ALIEN

11. Best Cinematography: ALIEN

12. Best Supporting Actress: ALIENS Jenette Goldstein

13. Best Supporting Actor: ALIENS Michael Biehn

14. Best Actress: TIE Sigourney Weaver

15. Best Actor: ALIEN Ian Holm

16. Best Scene: ALIENS Ripley with loader vs The Queen

17. Defining Moment: ALIEN Chestburst

18. Best Director: TIE Scott and Cameron

19. Best Picture: ALIEN

Totals after deductions:

• Alien: 8

• Aliens: 7

JOSH'S GOLDEN IDOLS

1. Best Location: ALIEN Nostromo

2. Best Character: ALIENS Ripley

3. Best Screen Duo: ALIEN Brett and Parker

4. Best Villain/Antagonist: ALIEN Nostromo Xenomorph

5. Best Hero/Protagonist: ALIENS Ripley

6. Best Kill: ALIENS Bishop torn in two by Xenomorph

7. WTF: ALIENS Newt knew of a faster, more convenient way to get to landing platform

8. Best Score or Soundtrack: ALIEN

9. Best Quote: ALIENS "Alright Sweethearts, what are you waiting for? Breakfast in bed? Another glorious day in the Corps! A day in the Marine Corps. is like a day on the farm. Every meal is a banquet! Every paycheck a fortune! Every formation a parade! I LOVE the Corps!"

10. Best Screenplay: ALIEN

11. Best Cinematography: ALIEN

12. Best Supporting Actress: ALIENS Jenette Goldstein

13. Best Supporting Actor: ALIENS Paul Reiser

14. Best Actress: ALIENS Sigourney Weaver

15. Best Actor: ALIEN Tom Skerritt

16. Best Scene: ALIENS Newt rescue attempt

17. Defining Moment: ALIENS Full screen face shot scene of Xeno before kill

18. Best Director: ALIEN Ridley Scott

19. Best Picture: ALIEN

Totals after deductions:

• Alien: 9

• Aliens: 9

AARON'S GOLDEN IDOLS

1. Best Location: ALIENS The Queens Chamber

2. Best Character: ALIENS Ripley

3. Best Screen Duo: ALIENS Drake and Vasquez

4. Best Villain/Antagonist: ALIENS Carter Burke

5. Best Hero/Protagonist: ALIENS Corporal Dwayne Hicks

6. Best Kill: ALIENS Gorman/Vasquez blow themselves up surrounded by aliens

7. WTF: ALIEN Ripley tosses around a box with Jones the cat and the cat makes no noise

8. Best Score or Soundtrack: ALIEN

9. Best Quote: ALIENS "Get away from her, you bitch!"

10. Best Screenplay: ALIENS

11. Best Cinematography: ALIENS

12. Best Supporting Actress: ALIENS Carrie Henn

13. Best Supporting Actor: ALIENS Lance Henriksen

14. Best Actress: ALIENS Sigourney Weaver

15. Best Actor: ALIENS Michael Biehn

16. Best Scene: ALIENS Ripley takes charge

17. Defining Moment: ALIEN Chestburst

18. Best Director: ALIENS Cameron

19. Best Picture: ALIENS

Totals after deductions:

• Alien: 2

• Aliens: 16

GOLDEN IDOL WINNER: ALIENS