The Evil Dead vs Evil Dead 2
What better way to get into the spirit of Halloween than by watching two Evil Dead movies! We decided to put The Evil Dead against Evil Dead 2. Which movie has the better tone? Which Ash do you prefer? Which movie has the best gore? Best kills? Graphic tree rape or the laughing deer head? There can only be one! Let's talk about movies!
BRAD'S GOLDEN IDOLS
Best Cabin: EV2
Best Screen Duo: EV2 Chainsaw & Boomstick
Best Deadite: EV2 Sweet Henrietta
Best Ash: EV2
Best Kill: EV Scotty dismembering Shelly
Best Gore: EV
WTF: EV Was Scotty raped by a tree?
Best Score or Soundtrack: EV2 Joseph LoDuca
Best Quote: EV2 Henrietta: "I'll swallow your soul! I'll swallow your soul! I'll swallow your soul!" Ash: [aims shotgun at Henrietta's face] "Swallow this!"
Best Screenplay: EV2 Sam Raimi & Scott Spiegel
Best Technical Achievement: EV2 Cinematography to build atmosphere
Best Supporting: TIE EV & EV2 Bob Dorian & John Peakes
Best Lead Performance: EV Betsy Baker
Best Scene: EV2 Laughter Scene
Defining Moment: EV2 Raimi's visual style
Best Director: TIE EV & EV2 Sam Raimi
Wildcard: EV Tree Rape Scene
Best Picture: Evil Dead 2: Dead by Dawn
Total after deductions:
The Evil Dead: 6
Evil Dead 2: 13
Wayne'S GOLDEN IDOLS
Best Cabin: EV2
Best Screen Duo: EV2 Ash & Annie
Best Deadite: EV2 Sweet Henrietta
Best Ash: EV2
Best Kill: EV Scotty dismembering Shelly
Best Gore: EV
WTF: EV2 Evil hand blood geyser
Best Score or Soundtrack: EV2 Joseph LoDuca
Best Quote: EV2 Mirror Ash: "We just cut up our girlfriend with a chainsaw. Does that sound "fine"?"
Best Screenplay: EV Sam Raimi
Best Technical Achievement: EV Cinematography
Best Supporting: EV Betsy Baker
Best Lead Performance: EV2 Bruce Campbell
Best Scene: EV Tree Rape Scene
Defining Moment: EV2 Ash Laughter Scene
Best Director: EV2 Sam Raimi
Wildcard: EV2 Necronomicon
Best Picture: Evil Dead 2: Dead by Dawn
Total after deductions:
The Evil Dead: 6
Evil Dead 2: 11
nATHAN'S GOLDEN IDOLS
Best Cabin: EV2
Best Screen Duo: EV Ash & Linda
Best Deadite: EV Linda
Best Ash: EV2
Best Kill: EV Scotty dismembering Shelly
Best Gore: EV
WTF: EV Nobody reacts when the force attacks
Best Score or Soundtrack: EV2 Joseph LoDuca
Best Quote: EV2 Henrietta: "I'll swallow your soul! I'll swallow your soul! I'll swallow your soul!" Ash: [aims shotgun at Henrietta's face] "Swallow this!"
Best Screenplay: EV Sam Raimi
Best Technical Achievement: TIE EV & EV2
Best Supporting: EV Shelly Rubber Chicken
Best Lead Performance: EV2 Bruce Campbell
Best Scene: EV Linda in the doorway
Defining Moment: EV Cheryl under the floor
Best Director: EV2 Sam Raimi
Wildcard: EV Budget
Best Picture: The Evil Dead
Total after deductions:
The Evil Dead: 10
Evil Dead 2: 7