adventures in videoland

Critics with attitude

John Wayne MARATHON 

BRAD'S GOLDEN IDOLS

  1. Best Film Location: Liberty Old Stagecoach
  2. Best Character: Shootist J.B. Books
  3. Best Screen Duo: El Dorado Cole Thornton & J.P. Harrah
  4. Best Villain/Antagonist: Liberty Liberty Valance
  5. Best Hero/Protagonist: Liberty (TIE) Tom Doniphon & Ransom Stoddard
  6. Best Kill: Katie Hasting's gun store explosion
  7. WTF: Katie 14 shots from a six shooter without reloading
  8. Best Score or Soundtrack: Katie Elmer Bernstein
  9. Best Quote: Liberty Maxwell Scott -"This is the West, sir. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend."
  10. Best Screenplay: Liberty Willis Goldbeck & James Warner Bellah
  11. Best Cinematography: Stagecoach Bert Glennon
  12. Best Supporting Actress: Stagecoach Louise Platt 
  13. Best Supporting Actor: El Dorado Robert Mitchum 
  14. Best Actress: Shootist Lauren Bacall
  15. Best Actor: Shootist John Wayne
  16. Best Scene: Stagecoach Authentic floating stagecoach
  17. Defining Moment: Stagecoach Used local indians. No whitewashing
  18. Best Director: Stagecoach John Ford
  19. Worst Picture: Rio Bravo
  20. Best Picture: The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance

Total after deductions:

  • The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance: 6
  • Stagecoach: 5
  • Rio Bravo: Negative 1
  • Shootist: 3
  • The Sons of Katie Elder: 2
  • El Dorado: 2

Kyle'S GOLDEN IDOLS

  1. Best Film Location: Liberty Doniphon's house
  2. Best Character: Liberty Ransom Stoddard
  3. Best Screen Duo: Rio Bravo John Chance & Dude
  4. Best Villain/Antagonist: Liberty Liberty Valance
  5. Best Hero/Protagonist: Liberty Tom Doniphon
  6. Best Kill: Liberty Liberty's death
  7. WTF: Mississippi as a racist chinaman
  8. Best Score or Soundtrack: El Dorado Nelson Riddle
  9. Best Quote: Liberty Maxwell Scott -"This is the West, sir. When the legend becomes fact, print the legend."
  10. Best Screenplay: Liberty Willis Goldbeck & James Warner Bellah
  11. Best Cinematography: The Shootist Bruce Surtees
  12. Best Supporting Actress: El Dorado Josephine MacDonald
  13. Best Supporting Actor: Liberty Lee Marvin 
  14. Best Actress: Liberty Vera Miles
  15. Best Actor: Katie John Wayne
  16. Best Scene: Rio Bravo Dude takes the lead again
  17. Defining Moment: Stagecoach First introduction to John Wayne
  18. Best Director: Liberty John Ford
  19. Worst Picture: Stagecoach
  20. Best Picture: The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance

Total after deductions:

  • The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance: 11
  • Stagecoach: Negative 1
  • Rio Bravo: 2
  • Shootist: 1
  • The Sons of Katie Elder: 1
  • El Dorado: 2

Nathan'S GOLDEN IDOLS

  1. Best Film Location: Rio Bravo Jail
  2. Best Character: El Dorado Cole Thornton
  3. Best Screen Duo: El Dorado Cole Thornton & Mississippi
  4. Best Villain/Antagonist: El Dorado Nelson McLeod
  5. Best Hero/Protagonist: Liberty Ransom Stoddard
  6. Best Kill: Shootist Death of J.B. Books
  7. WTF: El Dorado Moonwalking horse
  8. Best Score or Soundtrack: Rio Bravo Dimitri Tiomkin
  9. Best Quote: El Dorado "Can you hit the side of a barn with that thing?" .......
  10. Best Screenplay: Liberty Willis Goldbeck & James Warner Bellah
  11. Best Cinematography: The Shootist Bruce Surtees
  12. Best Supporting Actress: Rio Bravo Angie Dickinson 
  13. Best Supporting Actor: Rio Bravo Dean Martin 
  14. Best Actress: Shootist Lauren Bacall
  15. Best Actor: Shootist John Wayne
  16. Best Scene: El Dorado Let me hear you laugh....
  17. Defining Moment: Rio Bravo Technicolor
  18. Best Director: El Dorado Howard Hawks
  19. Worst Picture: Stagecoach
  20. Best Picture: El Dorado

Total after deductions:

  • The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance: 2
  • Stagecoach: Negative 1
  • Rio Bravo: 5
  • Shootist: 4
  • The Sons of Katie Elder: 0
  • El Dorado: 7