Spider-Man vs Spider-Man 2
In 2004, Sam Raimi directed Spider-Man 2, which many consider to be one of the best superhero films of all time. Tonight, we're pitting it against Raimi's first Spider-Man film, to see which is truly the greatest. Will it be the origin or the sequel? Who plays the better villain--Dafoe or Molina? Which film has the better Bruce Campbell cameo? Which film has the better J. Jonah Jameson scenes? Grab your web-shooters--and let's talk about movies!
COUSIN WAYNE'S GOLDEN IDOLS
Best Location: SM2 Doc Ock’s Hideout
Best Character: SM Norman Osborn/Green Goblin
Best Screen Duo: SM2 Peter Parker/Spider-Man & Aunt May
Best Villain/Antagonist: SM Norman Osborn/Green Goblin
Best Hero/Protagonist: SM2 Peter Parker/Spider-Man
Best Kill/Defeat: SM2 Hospital Tentacle Kills
WTF: SM2 Web running dry
Best Score or Soundtrack: Rubber Chicken
Best Quote: SM Uncle Ben: “Remember, with great power comes great responsibility.”
Best Screenplay: SM David Koepp
Best Special Achievement: SM2 Train Sequence
Best Supporting Actor/Actress: SM Cliff Robertson
Best Lead Actor/Actress: SM2 Tobey Maguire
Best Scene: SM2 Horror Hospital
Defining Moment: SM Death of Uncle Ben
Best Director: SM2 Sam Raimi
Wildcard: SM Wet T-shirt Award
Best Picture: Spider-Man
Total after deductions:
Spider-Man: 10
Spider-Man 2: 8
SETH'S GOLDEN IDOLS
Best Location: SM Abandoned Building (Final Fight)
Best Character: SM2 Otto Octavius/Doctor Octopus
Best Screen Duo: SM2 Peter Parker & J. Jonah Jameson
Best Villain/Antagonist: SM Norman Osborn/Green Goblin
Best Hero/Protagonist: SM Peter Parker/Spider-Man
Best Kill/Defeat: SM2 Hospital Tentacle Kills
WTF: SM2 Mary Jane/John Jameson love story
Best Score or Soundtrack: SM Danny Elfman
Best Quote: SM Peter Parker: [voiceover] Whatever life holds in store for me, I will never forget these words: "With great power comes great responsibility." This is my gift, my curse. Who am I? I'm Spider-man.
Best Screenplay: SM David Koepp
Best Special Achievement: SM Paving the way for modern superhero stories
Best Supporting Actor/Actress: SM2 J.K Simmons
Best Lead Actor/Actress: SM Tobey Maguire
Best Scene: SM2 Train Fight
Defining Moment: SM Upside Down Kiss
Best Director: SM Sam Raimi
Wildcard: SM Actor Facetime Award
Best Picture: Spider-Man
Total after deductions:
Spider-Man: 14
Spider-Man 2: 5
JESSE'S GOLDEN IDOLS
Best Location: SM The Brooklyn Bridge
Best Character: SM2 J. Jonah Jameson
Best Screen Duo: SM Norman Osborn & Green Goblin
Best Villain/Antagonist: SM2 Otto Octavius/Doctor Octopus
Best Hero/Protagonist: SM Peter Parker/Spider-Man
Best Kill/Defeat: SM Green Goblin’s Death
WTF: SM2 Jonah in Spidey costume
Best Score or Soundtrack: SM2 Danny Elfman
Best Quote: SM2 J. Jonah Jameson: “Tell her not to open the caviar.”
Best Screenplay: SM David Koepp
Best Special Achievement: SM VFX
Best Supporting Actor/Actress: SM2 James Franco
Best Lead Actor/Actress: SM Willem Dafoe
Best Scene: SM2 Train Fight
Defining Moment: SM Letting the thief get away
Best Director: SM2 Sam Raimi
Wildcard: SM2 The People of NY Award
Best Picture: Spider-Man
Total after deductions:
Spider-Man: 11
Spider-Man 2: 8
KYLE'S GOLDEN IDOLS
Best Location: SM New York City
Best Character: SM2 Otto Octavius/Doctor Octopus
Best Screen Duo: SM Norman Osborn & Green Goblin
Best Villain/Antagonist: SM Norman Osborn & Green Goblin
Best Hero/Protagonist: SM Peter Parker/Spider-Man
Best Kill/Defeat: SM2 Hospital Tentacle Kills
WTF: SM DC References
Best Score or Soundtrack: SM2 Danny Elfman
Best Quote: SM2 J. Jonah Jameson: “Miss Brant! Get me a violin!”
Best Screenplay: SM David Koepp
Best Special Achievement: SM2 Doc Ock’s Costume
Best Supporting Actor/Actress: SM2 J.K Simmons
Best Lead Actor/Actress: SM2 Tobey Maguire
Best Scene: SM2 Stopping the Train
Defining Moment: SM Bone Saw McGraw
Best Director: SM Raimi
Wildcard: SM2 The Bruce Campbell Award
Best Picture: Spider-Man 2
Total after deductions:
Spider-Man: 7
Spider-Man 2: 12